peace boat logo HomesearchSitemapContact us
What is Peace BoatVoyagesActivities in PortPeace EducationProject TeamsAdvocacy & CooperationNews & PressGet Involved


Special Report LAST UPDATE July 12, 2005
site design imagesparkle.com
October 3 - 7, 2003 Kashmir Forum
image
Members of the Kashmir Forum during a joint press conference with organizers from the World Social Forum 2004 in Chennai
The Concept
As an integral component of Peace Boat's peace-building, education and advocacy work, we organise forums onboard the ship to address regional issues. The neutral space provides the opportunity for stakeholders in a given issue from a broad range of perspectives to share their views openly with the aim of identifying and analysing the underlying causes and searching for collectively derived and mutually acceptable solutions that can be implemented at the community through to the regional level. Forums also provide an opportunity to raise awareness through formal and informal educational activities and interactions with the passengers onboard the ship. During this voyage, Peace Boat realised its long held goal of hosting a forum about the prolonged conflict over the State of Jammu and Kashmir*, bringing people together from India, Pakistan and Kashmir to hold a multilateral dialogue in a search for paths to a peaceful resolution to the Kashmiri conflict.
image
From L to R: Kathy Arlyn Sokol, Jaffar Ahmed, Ramu Ramdas, Altaf Khan, Ved Bhasin and Lolita Ramdas
Objectives
The aim of the forum was to provide a space for the participants whose perspectives on how to achieve a resolution to the conflict over Jammu and Kashmir are as diverse as their backgrounds, to look for common ground and to share initiatives for peace. Peace Boat hopes that the process will prove to be mutually beneficial to all participants and that the outcomes will contribute to the promotion of the peace in the region.
image
Kashmir Forum members meet the press in Chennai
Forum Report
Over the course of four days, the group engaged in both formal and informal discussions aimed at finding common ground. That the participants were unable to reach a stated agreement to create a formal position paper or document indicating precisely "what has been achieved" in many ways reflects the complexity as well as the entrenched nature of the conflict itself. In spite of this Admiral Ramdas, Mr Khan and Professor Jaffar Ahmed gave a press conference on the day we arrived in Chennai, India and it is an encouraging sign that this type of dialogue can take place. Peace Boat will continue to strive to help build links of solidarity and further the peace process in this war-ravaged region in the future.
EDUCATIONAL ACTIVITIES
Formal
The forum participants gave a series of public lectures, presenting their views over a three evenings to the international audience onboard. The series had an unintended benefit for the forum participants - the chance to meet and interact with over 600 mainly Japanese participants was also a learning opportunity, helping them to better understand and address the widespread lack of knowledge and concern about the 56 year war over Kashmir, compared with those in Palestine, Iraq and Afghanistan, for which the level of awareness is much higher.
image
Lolita Ramdas stresses a point about the importance of women's involvement in any peace process
Panel Discussion
One of the events held during the duration of the onboard forum was a panel discussion whose subject was the struggle for control over Jammu and Kashmir. Some of the key points raised were as follows.
  • Kashmir has common borders with Indian, Pakistan, Afghanistan and China and is considered to have unparalleled strategic value for both India and Pakistan
  • Kashmir is widely thought to be the cause and consequence of the prolonged India-Pakistan conflict, and the key reason for both countries having taken the decision to "go nuclear"
  • There are over 13 million Kashmiris who have been stateless for half a century (10 million people living on the Indian side of the line of control and 3.4 million people living under Pakistani administration).
  • The ratio of military to civilians in Kashmir is 1:7
  • Over 60,000 people have been killed in Kashmir since militancy started in 1989
image
The forum members with their team of interpreter/translators and volunteer helpers
Informal
A small-group interactive discussion session was also convened to allow Peace Boat participants to find out more about the Kashmir issue. One especially thorny question, "What do you think are the greatest fears of Pakistani and Indian governments about the theoretical possibility of independence of Jammu and Kashmir?" was met with the following two responses:
  1. "That both states would have to come to terms with a withdrawal from the arms race (and of course there are vested domestic interests in obtaining arms from abroad). For example, the Kashmir issue makes gives the military a degree of political power that enables it to overrule all other segments of society and rule the country. As for the people, in parts of the country, there would have to be re-education. An independent Kashmir would be an emotionally difficult proposition for people to accept. But if it happened, I think other people would befriend the Kashmiri people."

  2. Two basic fears that the Indian government may have:

First, the domestic fear in terms of real politik. All political parties have passed a resolution in government in the 1970s that Jammu and Kashmir is an integral part of India and under no circumstances will they part with an inch of the territory. So if any one of the parties seems to be getting 'soft' then they may sense they are committing political suicide.

Second, strategic and international geo-political situation in the region. Two portions of erstwhile Jammu and Kashmir are already taken by China and the growing presence of US forces in the region does pose in the long-term perspective a strategic violent interest because Jammu and Kashmir won't have the strategic ability to defend itself from outside forces. From the people's point of view, in various parts of India the further they are from Jammu and Kashmir the less in touch they are with the issue. Some feel we are wasting too much money on Jammu and Kashmir to keep this artificial position. In economic terms, the government spends more per capita on Jammu and Kashmir than on the rest of India."

Film Screening
Kathy Sokol screened the mini-documentary that she produced, "Fires in Kashmir: The Long War for Kashmiri Independence" to give people more of a visual idea of the kinds of conditions the people of Kashmir have been living under, such as heavy military presence and refugee camps. The irony being that Kashmir is a mountainous land of exquisite beauty ? whose landscape has been transformed from a once-famous tourist destination to a heavily-occupied region.

FORUM PARTICIPANTS
Ramu Ramdas (India)
A recent recipient of the "Graham Staines International Award" for promoting regional peace and communal harmony, Admiral Ramu Ramdas (retired) has been working for India-Pakistan friendship and cooperation since 1993. As Chairperson of Pakistan-India Forum for Peace and Democracy, his vision for the region has been for changing the existing situation of "conflict and confrontation" to that of "cooperation and convergence". His special focus has been on trying to find ways of resolving the long-standing Jammu and Kashmir question and has spearheaded efforts in building people to people relations and influencing decision makers in both countries.
image
Professor Jaffar Ahmed from the University of Karachi
Syed Jaffar Ahmed (Pakistan)
Dr Syed Jaffar Ahmed is Professor at the University of Karachi, lecturing in political science and history. With a Ph.D. from the University of Cambridge in 1993, Dr. Jaffar combines teaching and research with social activism working with human rights and women's organisations. He is also the coordinator of a group, "Education for Peace", which is involved in research and publications on peace issues.

Lolita Ramdas
Ms Ramdas is a teacher, peace activist, feminist and optimist who believes "Another World Is Possible" if many of us work together to make it happen. She also believes that women and youth must play a greater role in building peace and raising voices against war and violence.

Muhammad Altaf Khan
Born in Srinagar in Kashmir, Mr Khan is a lawyer and advocate by training. He is also a human rights activist who is working for greater interaction between different groups in Jammu and Kashmir, especially with students both in and outside of Kashmir. He has spent almost 18 months traveling around different parts of Pakistan to understand the complexities of the Kashmir problem and believes that the people of Kashmir can solve the problem if they are given the chance. Mr Khan has also traveled to almost all parts of Jammu and Kashmir including areas under Pakistani administration.
image
Mr Ved Bhasin, founder of The Kashmir Times, giving a Kashmiri perspective
Ved Bhasin
A journalist with over 50 years experience, Mr Bhasin is founding editor of "The Kashmir Times" - the first English newspaper in Jammu and Kashmir. He is also Chairman of the Kashmir Times Group of Newspapers, President of the Press Club of Jammu as well as President of the Jammu and Kashmir Consumers'Council. Mr Bhasin has been associated with India's socialist movement and Kashmir's freedom struggle since 1943 (at the age of 12), and is currently active amongst various NGOs working for peace, conflict resolution, freedom, human rights and the environment.

Kathy Aryln Sokol
Ms Sokol is a journalist, mother and concerned citizen of civil society for the right of Kashmiris to participate in any dialogue regarding their future. She has traveled extensively throughout Jammu & Kashmir and hopes to raise the awareness of the Kashmir conflict in world forums.
border graphic border graphic
United Nations
border graphic border graphic

border graphic border graphic
Friends of the Earth
border graphic border graphic

border graphic border graphic
gpac logo
border graphic border graphic

border graphic border graphic
International Peace Bureau
border graphic border graphic

border graphic border graphic
World Social Forum
border graphic border graphic

border graphic border graphic
Peace Now Korea Japan
border graphic border graphic


What is Peace Boat? | Voyages | Activities in Port | Peace Education | Project Teams | Advocacy & Cooperation | News & Press | Get Involved | Home | Sitemap | Contact us